Inside Costco: How a 92.9% Renewal Rate Turns Membership Fees into Pure Profit
With 73.3% of sales driven by Executive Members, Costco’s customer model isn’t just sticky—it’s engineered for scale and defensibility.
Trusted by 2,050+ private investors worldwide, Business Model Mastery is your daily ritual for building an edge over the market.
Each issue breaks down how great businesses truly operate—and what sets them apart by analyzing one company a day, helping you steadily build your own mental database of business models.
🧠 I handle the heavy lifting—digging into reports, filings, and key data—so you can focus on recognizing superior business models, comparing opportunities, and OUTTHINKING the market.
📖 With 180+ business models analyzed so far, you have a growing library of insights at your fingertips. Each analysis brings you closer to SHARPENING your edge and building the conviction to invest with clarity and confidence.
✅ If you haven’t yet, LOCK IN the lowest price before rates rise. The launch price has officially increased to $600/year — but for the next 10 spots only, you can still secure it for just $359 (40%+ permanent discount). This limited offer is valid until Sunday, May 18th, or until the final 10 spots are gone — whichever comes first.
➡️ The newsletter will remain daily—because consistent exposure is the fastest way to build a powerful mental database of business models. To make this habit easier to maintain, each issue will now begin with a sharp, clear Executive Summary, giving you the core insights in under a minute. You can go deeper when you have time—or stay on track even when you don’t. Like capital, knowledge compounds—small, daily insights lead to exponential returns. If you find this new format valuable, tap the ❤️ to let me know; your feedback directly shapes what stays.
Let’s begin.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1️⃣ Membership model drives profitability with over 76.2 million paid members and 92.9% renewal in the U.S./Canada; Executive Members account for 73.3% of global sales, creating sticky customer relationships.
2️⃣ Private-label brand Kirkland Signature contributes an estimated 25–30% of sales, offering 15–20% lower pricesthan national brands while delivering higher margins and supply chain control.
3️⃣ Warehouses carry under 4,000 SKUs, enabling faster inventory turnover, reduced labor costs, and high supplier volume leverage; SG&A expenses held at just 9.14% of sales, significantly below peers.
4️⃣ Gasoline (12% of sales) and fresh foods serve as traffic magnets, increasing visit frequency and basket size; gasoline presence in 719 locations enhances recurring customer behavior.
5️⃣ Employee wages average $31/hour with 93% retention for workers beyond one year; low turnover supports superior in-store efficiency and customer experience across 890 global warehouses.
Now, let’s step into the full article—where every detail comes together to reveal the complete picture. 👇🏻
There’s a business quietly reshaping the rules of retail. It doesn’t lure you in with glossy stores or flashy ads. It thrives on concrete floors, steel racks, and bare-bones lighting. But behind this stripped-down experience is a machine engineered for relentless efficiency, loyalty, and scale. It’s not just winning—it’s dominating, using a model so unique and finely tuned that even the most well-funded rivals struggle to replicate it.
Let’s take it apart. Not with surface-level platitudes, but by diving straight into the mechanisms that make it nearly unassailable.
The Price Illusion: A Business That Barely Makes Profit on What It Sells
On paper, its margins are razor-thin. Gross margin sits just above 10%. That’s far lower than traditional retailers, where 25% to 40% is the norm. At first glance, that seems like a problem. But it’s not a weakness—it’s the trap.
This company isn’t trying to make money on what it sells. It’s built to make money on who it sells to. The real engine isn’t the merchandise—it’s the membership.
Last year, it collected $4.83 billion in membership fees, which accounted for nearly all of its operating profit. Every new member, every renewal, fuels the flywheel. Once you understand this, everything else clicks into place.
Membership isn’t just a revenue stream. It’s a psychological contract. Members aren’t just shoppers—they’re stakeholders. Renewal rates? 92.9% in the U.S. and Canada. Globally, it’s 90.5%. That level of retention is almost unheard of in consumer businesses.
And there’s another layer: Executive Members. They pay double the standard fee and account for 73.3% of global net sales. That’s not just loyalty. That’s behavioral lock-in. The 2% cashback reward they receive incentivizes higher spending and tighter integration with the brand.
⸻
High Volume, Low Variety: The Anti-Walmart Strategy
Most retailers try to offer everything to everyone. This company does the opposite. While a typical big-box retailer might carry 100,000+ items, this one caps its SKU count at just under 4,000 per warehouse. Every product fights for its place. Only the fastest-moving, highest-value items survive.
This discipline creates enormous advantages:
• Inventory turnover is lightning fast.Products don’t sit—they flow.
• Suppliers get volume orders, often for just one SKU, allowing negotiation leverage that few others can match.
• Floor space is maximized.No fancy displays. Products stay in the pallets they arrived in, reducing labor costs and increasing speed.
This simplicity isn’t about cutting corners. It’s about engineering throughput.
⸻
Gasoline and Groceries: The Trojan Horses of Frequency
Some of the company’s most strategic moves happen in the least glamorous corners of the warehouse: the gas pump and the produce aisle.
Gasoline now represents about 12% of total sales. While fuel margins are slim, the strategic impact is massive. Gas stations—719 of them across key locations—drive foot traffic. Shoppers fill up their tank, then fill up their carts.
Meanwhile, fresh food and sundries—staples like eggs, meat, and paper towels—are the frequency drivers. These items anchor behavior. Customers come for the essentials and stay for the surprises, often leaving with much more than planned.
But there’s a twist. The business deliberately uses these essentials to lower margins—and expectations. It makes a conscious decision to take margin hits on core consumables, reinforcing its price reputation, then offsets those losses elsewhere.
⸻
Kirkland Signature: The Brand That Threatens Big Brands
Private label usually means cheaper and worse. Not here.
Kirkland Signature accounts for roughly 25–30% of total sales, and it doesn’t just mimic national brands—it often beats them. In taste tests, quality metrics, and customer satisfaction, Kirkland regularly matches or exceeds the top competitors.
Why does this matter?
Because private label is where margin and control intersect. The company doesn’t just sell Kirkland—it makes it, sources it, and designs it. That means:
• Better margins without raising prices.
• Resilience against supplier pressures.
• Sticky brand identity that builds trust over time.
Kirkland isn’t filler. It’s the sharpest tool in the company’s pricing arsenal.
⸻
Global but Grounded: Geographic Scale Without Overreach
Let’s break down where the money comes from.
72.4% of net sales originate in the U.S., with 13.7% from Canada and 13.9% from other international markets. But geography isn’t just about revenue—it’s about risk and growth.
California alone delivers 27% of U.S. net sales. That concentration is both a strength and a vulnerability. The state is home to the company’s highest-volume warehouses, but it also exposes the business to local economic shifts.
Internationally, growth rates outpace the domestic core. In 2024, non-U.S. sales rose by 9%, compared to 4% growth in the U.S. and 6% in Canada. New market entries—like China—are being approached cautiously, with an eye toward long-term customer behavior rather than quick gains.
⸻
Operational Discipline: No-Frills, High Output
Each warehouse is a 147,000 square foot engine of efficiency. Labor hours are lower because products are displayed in bulk, storage happens vertically, and operating hours are shorter than most competitors.
SG&A—selling, general, and administrative expenses—are just 9.14% of net sales. Compare that to Walmart (20.2%) or Target (20.7%), and the difference is staggering. That gap isn’t just operational—it’s philosophical.
The business avoids advertising almost entirely. It doesn’t chase seasonal trends. It rarely discounts. These decisions free up capital to reinvest in price reductions, which reinforces the value loop that keeps members renewing.
⸻
The Supply Chain as a Competitive Weapon
Most retailers rely on a chain of intermediaries. This company cuts as many of them out as possible. It operates a tightly integrated cross-docking system—bulk shipments are received at regional depots, sorted rapidly, and sent directly to warehouses.
There’s almost no backstock. That means:
• Lower holding costs
• Faster sell-through
• Minimal waste
It also means the company often sells items before it even pays suppliers. That’s a cash flow advantage many businesses can only dream of.
⸻
The Talent Edge: High Wages, High Retention
In an industry known for turnover, this company flips the script.
Entry-level workers now start at $19.50 per hour in the U.S. and Canada, with average hourly wages around $31.More than 93% of employees with over one year of tenure stay. That’s loyalty most retailers can’t buy.
But here’s the genius: By paying more upfront, the company saves more over time. Trained, motivated employees move product faster, reduce shrinkage, and deliver better service. The result? Higher productivity per square foot, even in a low-margin business.
⸻
The Hidden Value of Simplicity
Everything about this business screams restraint. Fewer SKUs. No ads. Minimal decoration. And yet, it produces one of the most defensible models in global retail.
Because every decision is engineered to serve one goal: deliver maximum value to the member.
That clarity becomes a moat. Not a metaphorical moat—an actual, measurable gap in:
• Customer loyalty
• Supplier relationships
• Margin efficiency
• Operational speed
And while other companies chase trends, this one sharpens its core.
⸻
Why Even the Best Competitors Struggle to Catch Up
Amazon has tech. Walmart has scale. Target has brand. But none of them have this combination:
• A cash-generating membership flywheel
• A beloved private label with category power
• A business that’s designed not to make money on merchandise—but on trust
And trust isn’t something you can buy with capital. It’s earned through decades of discipline. That’s why even the most well-capitalized rivals struggle to erode this model.
⸻
Conclusion: A Machine Built for the Long Game
This business doesn’t chase market trends. It creates them.
By weaponizing simplicity, aligning its incentives with its customers, and executing with ruthless consistency, it has built a structure that compounds strength over time. Not through explosive growth, but through durability, efficiency, and repeatability.
It’s a model that turns low margins into high retention, limited selection into overwhelming value, and basic warehouses into financial engines with precision-tuned gears.
If you’re studying world-class businesses—not just good ones, but truly great ones—you can’t afford to overlook this one. It’s not just a retailer. It’s a design for sustainable dominance.
Let’s keep sharpening your edge, one business model at a time.
See you tomorrow.
✋🏼 P.S: Before you go, I have a few important messages to share with you. 👇🏻
Getting value from Business Model Mastery? Hit LIKE (❤️)—it’s how you shape what comes next.
Every issue breaks down how great businesses really work—exposing hidden revenue streams, competitive advantages, and the factors that keep them ahead. I do the deep research so you can spot opportunities before the market catches on.
But here’s the deal: Liking this isn’t just appreciation—it’s a signal. It tells me what’s resonating, what to double down on, and which insights sharpen your edge the most.
If this helped you see smarter, think sharper, and invest better, hit LIKE (❤️) now—so I know to bring you more of it.
💡 Must-Reads You’ll Love
In Case You Missed Them: Our Most-Loved Must-Reads to Sharpen Your Edge 👇🏻
⏰ Your Limited-Time Offer
Right now, you can lock in a forever rate of $359/year—a permanent 40%+ discount from the regular $600/year. With only 10 spots originally available, just a few remain. Once they’re gone, the price rises—regardless of the deadline on Sunday, May 18th at 11:59 PM (California time). This isn’t just about saving money—it’s about securing a lasting edge. For less than a coffee a day, you’ll gain daily insights that break down how great businesses truly operate, analyzing one company at a time to help you steadily build a mental database of business models. I handle the heavy lifting—digging into reports, filings, and key data—so you can focus on recognizing superior business models, comparing opportunities, and outthinking the market.
And…
Payments are processed securely through Stripe, and your card won’t be charged until the subscription reaches $600/year—letting you lock in today’s discounted rate risk-free. While all past content is still free, it will soon become exclusive to paying subscribers. Subscribing now secures uninterrupted access at the current rate forever. This isn’t just a financial decision—it’s an investment in sharpening your thinking, understanding what sets winning businesses apart, and building a competitive edge that keeps you ahead of the market. Lock in your forever price today and start mastering business models to outthink—and outperform—other investors.
🚫 Check Your Spam Folder
Sometimes, emails with images or links end up in Spam or Promotions folders. If you don’t see the latest breakdown, please check there. Mark it as important, so you never miss a valuable insight. A single overlooked email could be the one that saves you from a big mistake or reveals an unexpected winner.
Disclaimer: This content is informational, not financial or professional advice. Investing involves potential loss, and by using this material, you agree to accept all risks and waive class-action rights. Full disclaimer is available on the About page.